Generalized personas versus inclusive research

Persona work is a staple of user-centric design: teams personify three or four people who supposedly represent the target audience so that the work stays aligned with their needs. Bailey draws a line between that familiar artifact and inclusive user personas, which are grounded in individual experiences rather than generalizations about groups.

Inclusive user research overlaps with traditional research only at a high level. The emphasis is on the individual experience and less on broad trends of behavior, and a primary goal is often to identify concrete barriers that prevent someone from accessing the content they want or need. Those barriers can defeat many navigation techniques at once. Teams chasing patterns, trends, and customer insights are better served by regular user testing; the same motivating factors they hope to uncover exist for disabled people too.

Where inclusive personas are documented apart from regular personas, they become easily dismissible as considerations. Disability is diversity, and personas that omit disability in at least some of their number misrepresent the people the abstract claims to serve.

Assistive technology in context

Equating assistive tooling with impairment is a common shortcut, and Bailey lists several reasons it fails:

  • Assistive technology is a means, not an end.
  • Some disabled people use more than one form of assistive technology, running them concurrently or switching between them as needed.
  • Some disabled people use none at all.
  • Not everyone who uses assistive technology has mastered it.
  • Disproportionate attention to one kind of assistive technology comes at the expense of others.
  • A solution can be technically compliant while remaining unintuitive or near-impossible to use in practice.

Accessibility enhancements in the physical world, such as curb cuts that also serve skateboarders or elevators that spare anyone the stairs, illustrate the inclusive half of the idea: everyone benefits instead of a narrow subset.

Approach before feature

When accessibility considerations fail, teams still need room for direct remediation. It's all about approach: adding drag-and-drop support, for instance, should start with identifying whether drag and drop is even needed to achieve the outcome the organization needs. A clever new pattern can step on other experiences, which runs counter to inclusiveness — the appeal of a novel UI idea is itself a blind spot when judging overall effectiveness.

Radical participatory design

Bailey points to radical participatory design (RPD) and a Cambridge University Press article describing it as participatory to the root or core: full inclusion of community members as equal and full members of the research and design team. RPD is not merely interaction, a method, a way of doing a method, or a methodology; it is a meta-methodology, a way of doing a methodology. Community members become equal stakeholders with decision-making power, an approach the article frames as a form of decolonization. Existing power structures are flattened and more evenly distributed.

The same discussion surfaces the model minority myth — the narrative that casts a minority group as high-performing and successful relative to others, painting Asian American children as high-achieving prodigies. It is a stereotype inside a stereotype, introducing exclusiveness into the pursuit of inclusiveness.

Practices that limit the pitfalls

  • Letting go of control leads to better outcomes.
  • Member checking: letting participants review, comment on, and correct content created from their input.
  • Scrutinizing the functions of our roles and how organizations compel us to undertake them to succeed within them.
  • Turning inward to the artifacts existing design and research processes produce, then finding opportunities for participants to add clarity and corrections along the way.