The three metrics and their thresholds

Google's May 2021 change folds Core Web Vitals into the signals that produce search rankings, alongside factors such as mobile-friendliness and safe browsing. Google arrived at the metrics through research into what constitutes a good user experience; the Chromium Blog's The Science Behind Web Vitals links to the underlying papers.

  • Largest Contentful Paint (LCP) — page-load speed: the largest element on the page should load within 2.5 seconds.
  • First Input Delay (FID) — the gap between a user attempting an interaction and the browser executing it: 100 milliseconds or less.
  • Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS) — layout stability during loading and interaction, including unexpected shifts. Impact and distance fractions are multiplied to produce the score, which should be 0.1 or less.

Why relevance still trumps page experience

Ranking depends on many signals, among them HTTPS and content structure, and relevant, well-presented content matters as much as page performance. A good page experience will not override great relevant content: a search for a specific brand returns that site at the top. The vitals start to matter when multiple results are plausible for a generic query — there, Google's ranking also weighs the page's user experience as measured by the Core Web Vitals.

Meeting the thresholds pays off

According to Google, sites that meet the Core Web Vitals thresholds see a 24-percent lower abandonment rate. Staying within the limits makes a site or app more engaging, and an appealing user experience attracts and retains visitors. Other search-optimization guidelines still apply, and images — especially the largest one in the viewport — should be optimized to load as fast as possible without degrading visual quality; balancing file size against fidelity is what makes an LCP image perform.

Reducing LCP

LCP concerns the largest piece of content visible in the viewport, above the fold — under common UX patterns, usually a hero image. Google watches <img> elements and <image> elements inside SVG; video counts only when it carries a poster attribute. Text-related block-level elements such as <h1>, <h2> and <span> also matter. The practical requirement is to load that largest element as quickly as possible.

Non-core vitals as diagnostic tools

Businesses should focus primarily on the Core Web Vitals, but other metrics still affect load experience, among them first contentful paint and the time to first purchase. They help explain a poor Core Web Vital: total blocking time and time to interact, for example, point at the causes of a bad FID. These vitals are not part of the core set, and Google's APIs allow custom metrics, which can be valuable for identifying and resolving performance issues.

Where the metrics are heading

Google has committed to per-year release cadences for major changes, announced well in advance — a topic covered in multiple talks at its conference late last year. Behind the scenes it collects field data continuously and checks it against user expectations. Items on the table:

  • First contentful paint is under consideration as another Core Web Vital.
  • The FID yardstick could tighten from 100 milliseconds to 75 or even 50.
  • CLS may be modified for single-page apps, which load only once, so an ideal CLS can degrade as the user clicks around and content moves.
  • Metrics for security, privacy and accessibility are on Google's radar, and it plans to fine-tune current metrics and launch new ones more frequently than major releases, including new Core Web Vitals.

Because Google collects real user data as analytics to set its standards, keeping pace with these developments is what keeps a site or app passing.