Okhsv and Okhsl: Rethinking the Colour Picker

Björn Ottosson has published an investigation into the HSL and HSV colour pickers that design applications have long relied on, asking a question that is rarely raised: are these models actually the right choice, or could something better be built?

Despite color picking playing a big role in a lot of applications, the design of color pickers isn’t a particularly well researched topic. While some variation exist in the widgets themselves, the choice of HSL or HSV is mostly taken for granted, with only a few exceptions.

Is their dominance well deserved or would it be possible to create better alternatives?

The overriding point is that HSL and HSV are inherited by default. Widgets differ from one another, but the underlying model is seldom questioned, and research into picker design is thin given how central colour picking is to so many applications.

Ottosson has also put together a playground for comparing the different possibilities side by side. The focus there is not the interface of the picker itself but the way the range of colours is expressed within the picker area.

The exercise is a case for questioning conventions that most of us simply accept, and the full write-up is available at the direct link.