A screen reader is an accessibility tool that reads and explains on-screen content to people who are blind or have low vision, letting them navigate a computer and carry out daily tasks. Several options exist, distributed through operating systems or open source projects. WebAIM's 2021 survey of 1,568 respondents found that more than 53.7 percent used JAWS on Windows, more than 30.7 percent used NVDA on Windows, and a little over 6.5 percent used VoiceOver on macOS — making these three the most popular choices.

Test methodology

The comparison was run by a front-end developer at a non-profit serving people with learning differences, who does not have a visual impairment and tests accessibility on a Mac using VoiceOver. To keep variables low, all three screen readers were tested on the same Wikipedia page about screen readers, in Chrome. The steps:

  1. Navigate by heading until the "Accessibility APIs" section. A 2016 survey by Heydon Pickering found most screen reader users navigate new pages by headings.
  2. Read the content and unordered list inside that section.
  3. TAB through the focusable items in the list.
  4. Jump to the Search field.
  5. TAB through a few items in the navigation section.

JAWS

JAWS (Job Access With Speech) is the most widely used screen reader in the world and runs only on Windows. Pricing ranges from a $90 yearly license to $1,605 for a perpetual license. It ships with predefined keyboard commands for web navigation, documented on its website.

JAWS Demo

Pressing H moves to the next heading and reads it with its level; pressing 2 or 3 reads Heading Level 2s and then Level 3s, which helps build a sense of page layout by heading level. In the "Accessibility APIs" section, DOWN ARROW steps through the unordered list. TAB moves focus to the next focusable item until reaching an element in another section, F focuses the search field, and further TAB presses land on the side navigation.

Assessment

JAWS is more customizable than the alternatives and offers more navigation options. It is the industry standard, and its large user base means abundant user-to-user support. The trade-offs:

  • More complicated to use than NVDA or VoiceOver, with a steeper learning curve.
  • Some commands are not intuitive, and there are many more for users to learn.
  • Unavailable on Mac, which limits its users.
  • Costs between $90 and $1,605.
  • Desktop and laptop use different key commands, which can hinder knowledge transfer and cause confusion.

NVDA

NVDA (NonVisual Digital Access) is Windows-only and must be downloaded from NVAccess. It is free but not preinstalled on Windows machines, and it is the second most popular screen reader worldwide per WebAIM's 2021 survey. Its keyboard commands are documented on its website.

NVDA Demo

Pressing H moves to the next heading: NVDA reads Heading Level 1, "Screen reader," then proceeds through Heading Levels 2 and 3. At "References," TAB focuses the next focusable items; after a few list items, ENTER follows a link to the New York Times page.

Assessment

NVDA supplied the needed information on screen, and its out-of-the-box keyboard commands were easy to use and learn. Being open source, it can be updated and fixed by the community, and being free makes it an affordable option for Windows users. The drawback is availability: NVDA is not offered on Mac, which limits its users.

VoiceOver

VoiceOver is the screen reader built into the Mac — and only the Mac. It is free and already installed, so users need not download or purchase extra software, removing a barrier inherent in the computer setup. Its keyboard commands are documented on Apple's site.

VoiceOver Demo

In the demo, the VoiceOver Command (Control+Option) plus Command+H cycles through headings in order — Heading Level 1 "Screen Reader," Heading Level 2 "Contents," Heading Level 3, and so on. In the "Accessibility APIs" section, VoiceOver Command plus RIGHT ARROW tells VoiceOver to read the section, and repeating it navigates within the section. At the third list item, TAB moves focus onward. After a few more TAB presses, VoiceOver Command plus U opens the Form Control Menu; DOWN ARROW reaches the "Search Wikipedia" option, ENTER focuses the form field, and TAB continues into the navigation section.

Assessment

VoiceOver is easy to use and learn, its commands are intuitive, and it is a free tool installed on every macOS device. Its limits: it is unavailable on Windows, which limits its users, and it is not an app, so it receives updates only when Apple releases a macOS update.

Comparison and conclusions

JAWSNVDAVoiceOver
Operating SystemWindowsWindowsmacOS
Price$90 – $1695FreeFree
# of users50%30%6%
Ease of Use (subjective)HardEasyEasy

For basic screen reader testing, the three follow a broadly similar keystroke pattern, and knowledge gained from one carries over to the others. Each has its pros and cons, and the right choice ultimately depends on user preference and the operating system in use.