Favicon Study: PNG Dominates, and Many .ico Files Are Really PNGs

A favicon research project from iconmap.io surveyed a large set of sites and produced a map of the results, along with a handful of findings worth pulling out of the data.

The measured cost of a favicon is modest but not negligible: the average favicon network request takes 130ms, based on the project's cloud instance. That figure comes from a fast environment, and the request is for a file virtually every site on the web serves — which is a decent argument for getting the implementation right and making sure browsers download only one icon, ideally an SVG.

The format breakdown runs against intuition. Rather than the legacy ICO format, PNG is the clear majority: 71.6% of <link rel="icon"> images are PNG.

There is a stranger detail underneath that. Of the files served at /favicon.ico, 21.1% are actually PNGs in disguise — a reminder that for browsers file extensions carry little meaning, and what matters is the content type.

The researchers themselves flag uncertainty in their method, but the dominant color in the analysis so far is purple. If that holds up it would make some sense: unless a site ships separate favicons for dark mode, picking white or black is a risky choice these days.