Ken Kocienda's argument that web browsers exist to view documents — and that extending them beyond that is "the biggest wrong turn in the history of computing" — reads as a claim that web development itself was a mistake. There is an obvious irony: the tweet making the case was posted on Twitter, a website, and was followed by a link to job postings. That is the web being used as something other than a document viewer, to distribute a message and recruit. Arguing that cars are bad while driving to the grocery store is roughly the same shape of contradiction.

“Water not wet” reports man standing in ocean. https://t.co/5oUUdWARTU

— Chris Coyier (@chriscoyier) January 31, 2021

The argument may instead be that browser capability growth was the error, not that browsers lack the capability today. If so, what follows? Stripping features? Reducing browsers to document viewers, and leaving the rest of the platform to proprietary walled gardens? A highly capable open web is the better outcome: it lets us build on open standards rather than inside closed platforms, and URLs by themselves are a reason to build there.

The genuine tension

Getting the amount of capability right still deserves care. Noam Rosenthal's "Should The Web Expose Hardware Capabilities?" works through that question starting from Alex Russell's "Platform Adjacency Theory":

I relate with the author's passion for keeping the open web relevant, and with the concern that going too slow with enhancing the web with new features will make it irrelevant. This is augmented by my dislike of app stores and other walled gardens. But as a user I can relate to the opposite perspective — I get dizzy sometimes when I don't know what websites I'm browsing are capable or not capable of doing, and I find platform restrictions and auditing to be comforting.

Moving slowly and carefully — deliberately slow, rather than stalled — is a defensible answer. In practice that is what happens now, even if by accident. Google pushes the platform forward quickly; Apple holds back, citing security concerns; occasionally the roles reverse. Mozilla matters, but its platform decisions currently carry little weight in the overall direction of the web, which leaves the momentum largely with two major browser vendors.