On the Web, Everything Is Still Paper
Writing at maggieappleton.com, Maggie Appleton examines paper as perhaps the most foundational metaphor underlying the web.
Paper documents were the original metaphor for the web. […]
The page you’re reading this on still mimics paper. We still call it a page or an HTML document. It follows the same typographic rules and conventions – black text on white backgrounds and a top-to-bottom / left-to-right heirarchical structure.
The metaphor even surfaces in naming conventions. In the ShopTalk Discord, the notion of CSS custom properties called --ink and --paper came up as abstractions for color and background-color, and the author finds something clearer about what those words mean.
Where Paper Falls Short
Appleton also covers the drawbacks of paper-based thinking, drawing on critiques from Ted Nelson, including this one:
We treat the page as the smallest unit of linkable information, instead of the sentence or paragraph.
Jump links or Chrome's newer link to highlight feature arguably push back on that, though the author accepts the broader point.
What Comes After Paper
Will the web's central metaphor eventually change? The author considers it highly likely. The interactivity and behavior users expect today are vastly different from past expectations, and that drift is set to continue, with such updates accelerating it. Candidate metaphors floated for some future point include "alternate neighborhood," "second brain," or "dedicated assistant."



