Anchors are interactive elements, not links
Heydon's piece on the anchor element makes a terminology point worth repeating: what we casually call a "hyperlink" is an <a>, an interactive element — and only when it carries an href. The text inside it functions as a label, so it should describe the destination or the action it performs.
Web developers and content editors, the world over, make the mistake of not making text that describes a link actually go inside that link. This is collosally [sic] unfortunate, given it’s the main thing to get right when writing hypertext.
URLs as durable design decisions
Jim Nielsen's earlier writing on URL design covers the destination side of the same problem. He has argued that human-friendly slugs carry information that can change, because humans make errors:
If a slug is going to be human-friendly, i.e. human-readable, then it’s going to contain information that is subject to change because humans make errors.
Changing a URL's contents is a breaking change. A good URL such as:
<a href=“css-tricks.com/almanac”>
becomes something else if rewriting "Almanac" to "Docs" is judged an improvement:
<a href=“css-tricks.com/docs”>
Server redirects from /almanac to /docs keep old requests working, but they accumulate as a maintenance obligation. CSS-Tricks, as one example, holds a large collection of redirects, many created for simple human mistakes — including typos. Take the final installment of the CSS-Tricks Chronicles from 2001, misspelled in its title as "CSS-Tricks Choronicles XLI" and reflected in the URL:
https://css-tricks.com/css-tricks-chronicle-xxxxi/
That history weighs on efforts to reorganize roughly 7,000 articles. For years the site used a flat structure in which an article's title, lightly edited, became its URL:
<a href=“css-tricks.com/geoff-is-on-another-dumb-rant”>
Classifying content by type — articles, links, Almanac entries, guides — would require inserting another path layer, which breaks the original URLs:
<a href=“css-tricks.com/soapbox/geoff-is-on-another-dumb-rant”>
Link rot and the universal identifier
Jay Hoffman has also written about URLs. He points out that one-way links, where anyone can link to anything, are what make the web universal; the original name for URLs was URIs, Universal Resource Identifiers, and Berners-Lee described that universality as essential. Dead links matter even in aggregate, and although the Internet Archive and similar efforts repeatedly rescue the web during periods of loss, link rot is arriving faster than those efforts can keep up with.
Related reporting covers Google's plan to sunset its URL shortener. All goo.gl addresses created since the tool launched in 2018 fall under this notice:
Any developers using links built with the Google URL Shortener in the form https://goo.gl/* will be impacted, and these URLs will no longer return a response after August 25th, 2025. We recommend transitioning these links to another URL shortener provider.
Google-carved URLs produced by its own apps, such as Maps sharing, are unaffected:
Note that goo.gl links generated via Google apps (such as Maps sharing) will continue to function.
The change is closer to pruning than to rot — more a deliberate shave than a gradual graying. Nick Heer sees an upside:
In principle, I support this deprecation because it is confusing and dangerous for Google’s own shortened URLs to have the same domain as ones created by third-party users. But this is a Google-created problem because it designed its URLs poorly. It should have never been possible for anyone else to create links with the same URL shortener used by Google itself.
The underlying fault was in the URL design, and the fix unavoidably removes part of the web's context.



